Google: Louisville, KY Is The Most Obscene City In The U.S.

|

louisville.jpgAmbitious prosecutors are now trying to shut down Internet pornographers by trying them in towns where conservative "community standards" make an obscenity conviction more likely. A novel defense now being tried in a Pensacola, Fla. obscenity case: Using Google Trends to prove that the town's "community standards" are more prurient than prosecutors are willing to admit.

The idea: If Google proves that local residents search for "sex" more than they do for, well, anything else, then the defense can argue that Internet pornographers are just satisfying a local need, not corrupting innocent minds. We like this idea, though we're dubious that the courts are going to go for it.

But suppose they do? Where then, according to Google, does an obscenity defendant stand the best chances? In other words: What city's residents are most interested in looking up dirty stuff on the Web?

Google Trends says: Louisville, Kentucky.

We know! We were surprised, too -- almost as surprised as we were to see neither New York City or San Francisco in our top 10. The full list:

The 10 American Cities Most Likely To Search For Obscene Material

  1. Louisville, KY
  2. Rochester, NY
  3. Philadelphia, PA
  4. Newark, NJ
  5. Los Angeles, CA
  6. Irvine, CA
  7. Pittsburgh, PA
  8. Las Vegas, NV
  9. Albany, NY
  10. Orlando, FL

Here's how we got there: We used George Carlin's (R.I.P.) "Seven Dirty Words" as obscenity proxies, and looked up each of them on Google Trends. We restricted the results to the United States, and noted the top 10 cities querying each of the seven words. Top scores went to cities that showed up on multiple lists; to break ties, we assigned weight values depending on a city's rank on individual lists. Note that Google weights its own results to account for population: The cities listed above showed the greatest percentage of searchers looking for dirty words, not the greatest number of people. Want to see the raw data and our math? Click here.

Again, we're dubious that the courts are going to allow Google to stand in as an obscenity barometer anytime soon. But we'll be keeping an eye on the Pensacola case. And if this does work, we expect to see a flood of Web porn companies heading for the Kentucky border.

 

See Also: Do The Good People Of Florida Think Your Website Is Obscene? You Better Hope Not.

George Carlin, RIP



< Prev. Story
Next Story >

24 Comments

Kristin (URL) said:
I thought this was really interesting. Apparently Google is being used a lot in court cases now. (Who knew?!)

Jim L (URL) said:
Man, Louisville, KY is wild. Here are some additional rankings that are off the chart...

Louisville, KY

nude teens - Rank #3
underage teens - Rank #1
sex with animals - Rank #3
old women naked - Rank #1
sex with dead people - Rank #2

These people are really on the edge!


CV said:
A novel approach for sure, but doesn't really have any legs to stand on. First, you would have to be able to somehow verify that users doing the query were actually from that community were the obsecity laws apply. Example - Tourists in Orlando. Second, what percentage of the community is generating the obscene searches? 10 percent? 50 percent? It could be a small group of people generating most of the queries. Do you throw out the community standards because of an active minority? I don't think so. However, these Google search results could be used in these communities as a reason to review their obscenity laws, and through local involvement determine whether they want to change it or keep it as is.

Gordon said:
I don't trust Southerners. Southerners aren't really friendly, it's all fake, it's all superficial, it's meanness with a polite veneer. I have grown to have an innate distrust of southerners due to what I feel is an innate passive-aggression, in which politeness is wielded like a club or a knife. Some people seem to believe you can say the most horrible, hostile shit and get away with it as long as you add "Bless her heart" after the fact. F**K that.

RH said:
There is possibly some reasons why, lets say New York or Frisco do not show up in the approach taken. Why resort to the Internet in those cities when one can simply satisfy those carnal impulses by leaving the computer and going to the public schools?

Sergay said:
The ivy leaguer/googler sees the rest of you hicks as nothing more than trailer park trash. you know their biases are built into Google Trends, so SF/NYC will never make it onto their top 10. their algorithms give a much lower ranking say to obscene searches from an iphone in SF .

@Sergay

The Ivy Leaguer? Well Philadelphia, home of U Penn, came in at #3.

DNO said:
So let me get this straight..these prosecutors are going to court to remove the porn from the internet. Ok then. Are there any quotes of the "I will not rest until every piece of porn is removed" style?

Are their ambulance chasing days behind them, no viagra causing delusions? They can always create a support group, "porn watch" to assist with their courtroom antics.

Tecumseh said:
Sad to know that our great hunting lands are now home to such vile humans. KEN-TUC-EE was once a great no-mans land where truces among all the great nations were upheld and very productive hunts were had. How "productive" the settlers became...

crawford said:
@Gordon, I'm sure you mean well, bless your heart.

Diane said:
Everyone is missing the point.

It matters little to me where the vile things mentioned are being searched. Truly, if it isn't one vice, it's another. We all are human and all suffer from the great human condition: our fallen nature. Certainly, one could say that our tastes are descending into more and more base obscenity as our culture declines.

What is most troubling is the relativistic nature of this study. We MUST hold to some objective standard or else only "might makes right." If a court determines that one's actions are within the realm of normalcy given the predilections of local society, it will matter little whether it is legal, or not.

I am libertarian at heart...but even I know that there must be law and justice and FOR there to be law and justice, there must be absolutes. Otherwise, it's all shifting sand based on morphing legal precedent. Things which once were unheard of will, according to legal/social "evolution," be common.

Question is: who decides what Truth IS?

Siddhartha Vicious said:
Diane, how about this for a start, "I am the way, the TRUTH, and the light."

ZAXZAN said:
@Siddhartha Vicious are you -

A/ The second coming.
Two/ Full of self importance.
C/ Deluded.
4/ Funny.
IV/ Sad.
Sex/ A frequent attendee of the non compos mentis toppers char shindig.


Or - All of the above and as such actively engaged in a pious cult.

;)





Diane said:
Sidd-

First, it was more of a rhetorical question.

Second, it is: "I am the way, the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me." John 14:6, NIV.

But, He did also declare Himself to be the light of the world, so, your point is valid. :o)

Zax-

Sidd was certainly espousing his view of reality. But, is that any different than your own? This is not relativism but recognition. There must be an absolute, and one overarching truth, but belittling it only defeats your purpose and degrades the discourse. Try again...this time being intellectually honest about your bias, like the rest of us.

jay said:
I used the data from the spreadsheet and took a different approach. For each word, the top 10 cities were given a value between 1 and 10, where 10 went to the number one city and 1 went to the last city in the top 10. If there was a tie, then the city who searched more words "won"

This approach is based more on their Google ranking as opposed to how many of the dirty words they search for.

That was done for each search term, and then totaled for each city. The top 10 was slightly different:

1 Louisville, KY, USA
2 Rochester, NY, USA
3 Philadelphia, PA, USA
4 Irvine, CA, USA
5 Newark, NJ, USA
6 Las Vegas, NV, USA
7 Pittsburgh, PA, USA
8 Albany, NY, USA
9 Portland, OR, USA
10 Richardson, TX, USA
11 Boston, MA, USA
12 Orlando, FL, USA
13 New York, NY, USA
14 Tampa, FL, USA
15 Los Angeles, CA, USA
16 Elmhurst, IL, USA
16 Meriden, CT, USA
17 Providence, RI, USA
18 Salt Lake City, UT, USA
19 St Louis, MO, USA
20 San Antonio, TX,
21 Norfolk, VA, USA
21 Oklahoma City, OK, USA
21 Sacramento, CA, USA
22 Chicago, IL, USA
23 Seattle, WA, USA

Southern Gent said:
Gordon,

Maybe you're just a prejudiced bigot who likes to defame whole groups of people based on your own ignorant biases?

Just a thought.

Oh yeah, bless your heart.

passive-aggressive southerner said:
Gordon, this Kentuckian is happy that you feel that way. In fact, you just tell all your buddies, bless their hearts, that they might want to keep the hell away from Kentucky.

You just never know how we'll take to strangers.

todd said:
gordon -

i'm pretty sure there are unfriendly, superficial, passive-aggressive people all over the place, not just here in kentucky. we also have some nice people.

nice people, mean people everywhere. it's intellectually unsophisticated to over-generalize. but i don't blame your simplicity on your geographical location :-)

yee haw!





J-bag said:
Haha, interesting. I wouldn't really say Louisville is "southern," though, by any means.

I'm from Louisville, and the motto on walls and bumper stickers all across town are "Keep Louisville Weird!" Looks like we continue to succeed. It is funny though to see so many people talking smack about Kentucky though...I mean you have to be pretty obscene to even care about this article, so who are you to talk. Gordon shouldn't trust anyone if it took him this long to learn the "South's" secret weapon...I mean seriously did you ever really believe we were "Southern Gentlemen"? If so you are naive and uneducated in the history of the South. I'm proud to be from a town this fucked up, and hope you fascist can never put a stop to it!

Methodology said:
2 things:
I was recently in Louisville, where I was told by a resident it was the northernmost Southern city I could find. And the people there were really nice.

More important: Did it occur to the person who put this survey together that Carlin's recent death might do something to skew the statistics JUST A LITTLE BIT? Perhaps the people Googling Carlin's "seven dirty words" had just heard about them in his obituary and were curious. Or just wanted to relive their youths. Or couldn't remember what the words were to tell their kids.

wow gold (URL) said:
Buy WOw gold, cheap world of warcraft woW gOld, buy gold warcraft WOw gold? We sell World of Warcraft wow gold,
Cheap wOw Gold Look here! wow GoLd Store Welcome you! Look here to Buy WOw GOld, Cheap WOw golD, woW goLD Power Leveling,
buy Cheap WoW gold in here.

sohbet chat sohbet chat çet sohbet chat özcan sarıca ile kurtlar vadisi pusu 3.sezon 1.seo yarışması aytug akdogan ödüllü 1. seo yarışması ve yurtta barış dünyada barış sesli chat sesli sohbet sesli görüntülü chat görüntülü sohbet kameralı sohbet kameralı chat bayan arkadaş görüntülü çet sesli muhabbet kızlarla sohbet kızlarla chat kameralı çet kameralı sohpet kızlarla çet chat gizli kamera güvenlik sistemleri kamera güvenlik kamerası cilt bakımı cilt bakım ürünleri ıslak mendil kolonyalı mendil kolonyalı mendil güvenlik kamerası gizli kamera kamera canlı sohbet sohpet sohbet sesli sesli chat sesli sohbet kameralı sohbet kameralı chat görüntülü chat görüntülü sohbet bayanlarla sohbet sesli muhabbet bayanlarla chat kızlarla sohbet bayan arkadaş görüntülü çet sesli çet sesli sohpet seslichat sesliçet kameralı sohpet kameralı çet kızlarla sohpet kızlarla çet sesli sohbet sesli sohbet sesli sohbet sesli chat sesli chat chat çet ek iş ek gelir mirc avşa adası avşa avşa adası avşa tatil tatil köyleri "Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr" Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr "Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr" "Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr" Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr özcan sarıca ile kurtlar vadisi pusu 3.sezon 1.seo yarışması özcan sarıca ile kurtlar vadisi pusu 3.sezon 1.seo yarışması aytug akdogan ödüllü 1. seo yarışması ve yurtta barış dünyada barış aytug akdogan ödüllü 1. seo yarışması ve yurtta barış dünyada barış "adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi başlıyor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yarışması" adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi başlıyor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yarışması adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi başlıyor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yarışması "adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi başlıyor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yarışması" "adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi başlıyor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yarışması" adtech ile reklam 2.0 dönemi başlıyor ve Trkycmhrytllbtpydrklcktr r10.net seo yarışması ıslak mendil ıslak mendil kolonyalı mendil kolonyalı mendil paketleme ambalajlama paket web tasarım seo refreshing towel perde tatil kozmetik haber joy türk radyo aşk haber video tatil tekstilkent yabancı personel çalışma izni



MyTechSis Otomobil Ödüllü Seo Yarışması


MyTechSis Otomobil Ödüllü Seo Yarışması


sohbet
sohbet
sohbet
chat
msn
kimsesiz
belediye baskanlari
belediye baskanlari
belediye baskanlarimiz
belediye baskanlarimiz
belediye baskanlarimiz
belediye baskanlarimiz
belediye baskanlarimiz
belediye baskanlarimiz
erotik resimler
senato adayları
millet vekili adaylari
belediye baskanları
komik fikralar
manzara resimleri
tente

Join the discussion