Avenue A SVP: Microsoft + Yahoo = Irrelevant

|

Give credit to Avenue A SVP Jeff Lanctot, now a Microsoft employee (via the aQuantive acquisition), for not pulling punches in his interview with us. Instead of the usual blather about parent-sub harmony, synergy, etc., Jeff shot straight about what it's like to work for Microsoft while placing advertising across Yahoo, Google, and the rest of the web.

In short? It's a potential conflict of interest:

If our clients think for one minute that we are favoring Microsoft over AOL, we would lose that client tomorrow. Likewise if the MSN sales team is thought to be favoring us or providing us with information at the expense of other agencies or advertisers that business would go somewhere else. So, it's really high-risk for really no reward.

This certainly begs the question why Microsoft wants to own an ad agency. We suspect its eventual answer will be, "We don't."

The Lanctot straight-talk express didn't stop there, by the way. Worried about Microsoft+Yahoo together cornering the market on web advertising? Don't worry, Jeff says. Portals like MSN and Yahoo are getting less and less relevant:

There's a perspective that going from three portals to two is bad for buyers. But spend is actually moving away from portals and much more broadly across the web, so I'm actually not concerned about moving from three to two, because we are really moving from 3 to 800.



< Prev. Story
Next Story >

6 Comments

dean wormer said:
$10 bucks says they sell Ave A Razorfish in a year. All they wanted was Atlas and DrivePM, networking and ad serving.

joeblow said:
Henry, do you mean by extension that MSFT shouldn't have acquired aQuantive as well?

All this ad agency stuff is just confusing to me. What does Razorfish do that aQuantive didn't already do without Razorfish?


Peter Kafka said:
Jeff's no dummy. We asked him what he thought about the MSFT-YHOO deal and he studiously avoided offering a concrete opinion, except that he's supportive of his owners. That said we do appreciate his candor about the state of web advertising in general, which is why we ran a Q&A w/him.

Henry Blodget said:
My read: He thinks it's ludicrous that Microsoft owns Avenue A (which they got with the aQuantive deal). I expect Microsoft probably thinks it's ludicrous, too.

I don't think he rendered an opinion on the Yahoo deal. Certainly doesn't seem to view it as an earth-shaking event, though.

joeblow said:
Maybe you didn't ask Jeff what exactly he thinks MSFT will gain from buying Yahoo, if anything... or I'm too dumb to know if you indeed asked it and he did answer it but it's only that I'm just too dumb to understand the answer.

Which of all these, please?

All I could put together from his remarks is that web advertising is going away from the portals... unless I'm dumber than I think I am and even that wasn't what he said.
--
In other words, what's the bottom line of Jeff's thinking?


Join the discussion