SEC Investigating Fraudulent Steve Jobs Heart Attack Report
As we have chronicled in detail, CNN's iReport citizen journalism site reported this morning that Apple's Steve Jobs had had a "severe heart attack" and been rushed to the hospital. The report briefly clobbered Apple's stock. About twenty minutes after we and Bloomberg reported that the iReport was false, CNN removed it. Later, CNN declared the report "fraudulent."
We expected that the false report would lead to an SEC investigation, and, indeed, the SEC has already launched one.
Here's CNN's statement about the Steve Jobs heart attack story that appeared on its iReport site this morning:
iReport.com is an entirely user-generated site where the content is determined by the community. Content that does not comply with Community Guidelines will be removed. After the content in question was uploaded to iReport.com, the community brought it to our attention. Based on our Terms of Use that govern user behavior on iReport.com, the fraudulent content was removed from the site and the user's account was disabled.
Later, the company confirmed Bloomberg that it is talking to the SEC:
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating the origin of a false report on a CNN citizen journalist Web site that Apple Inc. Chief Executive Officer Steve Jobs had a heart attack and was hospitalized. The agency's enforcement unit is trying to determine whether the iReport.com posting was intended to push down the company's stock price. CNN is cooperating with the SEC's probe, network spokeswoman Jennifer Martin said.
So obviously, this imbroglio will force CNN to rethink iReport and its user-generated news concept, right? No, it's not, Jennifer Martin tells us. The site has policies that forbid people from making up stories about the health of the celebrity CEOs, she points out: "For the user-generated community of ireport.com, it's been working up to this point."
See Also: Apple Denies Steve Jobs Heart Attack Report: "It Is Not True"




The ireport was from a new user with no prior posts. How the hell can anyone believe that is credible news?
Yes the guy needs to go to jail, I'm sure CNN have logged his IP and handed over any other info to SEC.
"...is beyond reproach" means it's not reproachable. In other words, it's a great thing they did over at CNN. According to your next sentence though, no, it wasn't.
Anyone find out who the short was? Curiosity's killing me.
-mmmmarah
The founding fathers roll over in the graves because of agencies like them - with rights come responsibilities, and the first amendment allows such freedoms of the press, but CNN has blatantly abused their powers of the press in the past by not asking relevant or tough questions, by skewering and slanting news stories, and now most recently by putting their reputation behind the falsified story that some s-disturber came up with. Report, don't facilitate. Let blogger, livejoural and others handle that.
This is a case of old media not understanding how web 2.0 works and not putting enough checks and balances in place to prevent manipulation.
Shame on CNN
I will agree that CNN should be held responsible, if not necessarily accountable, for this debacle. The individual who posted the story should be the one prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law for posting fallacious information as fact on a world news source. People must learn that there are consequences to their actions.
K-